top of page

Scary Story Writing Prompts to Ignite Your Imagination

  • Writer: Jason J. Cross
    Jason J. Cross
  • 11 minutes ago
  • 4 min read

Ever found yourself staring at a blank page, itching to write a spine-chilling tale but stuck for ideas? Yeah, me too. Sometimes, all it takes is a spark - a little nudge to get those creepy creative juices flowing. What if I told you that a simple prompt could unlock a world of eerie possibilities? Let’s dive into some thrilling story starters that will have your imagination running wild and your fingers itching to type.


Why Use Scary Story Writing Prompts?


You might wonder, why bother with prompts at all? Well, prompts are like a flashlight in a dark forest. They guide you when you’re lost, giving you a direction without stealing your creative freedom. When it comes to horror, a good prompt can:


  • Trigger unexpected ideas you wouldn’t have thought of on your own.

  • Help you overcome writer’s block by providing a clear starting point.

  • Push you to explore new themes or settings you haven’t tried before.

  • Keep your writing fresh and exciting by challenging your usual style.


For example, imagine a prompt that asks you to write about a town where no one can leave after sunset. Suddenly, you’re not just writing a story; you’re building a world filled with tension and mystery. That’s the power of a well-crafted prompt.


Eye-level view of an old, abandoned house at dusk
An eerie abandoned house setting the mood for a scary story

How to Turn Prompts into Full-Blown Stories


Getting a prompt is just the beginning. The real fun starts when you take that tiny seed and grow it into a full narrative. Here’s how I usually approach it:


  1. Pick the prompt that excites you the most. If it doesn’t give you chills or spark curiosity, move on.

  2. Ask yourself questions about the prompt. Who is involved? What’s at stake? Why is this happening?

  3. Create a quick outline. Jot down the beginning, middle, and end. Don’t worry about perfection.

  4. Add sensory details. What does the place smell like? What sounds fill the air? These details pull readers in.

  5. Build suspense gradually. Don’t reveal everything at once. Let the tension simmer and grow.

  6. End with a twist or unresolved mystery. Leave your readers thinking long after they finish.


For instance, if your prompt involves a haunted mirror, think about who owns it, what it shows, and how it changes over time. Maybe the mirror reveals not just reflections but hidden secrets or future horrors.


My Favorite Scary Story Writing Prompts


Ready for some inspiration? Here are a few of my top picks that have sparked some of my best creepy tales. Feel free to tweak them or combine ideas to make them your own.


1. The Whispering Forest


You enter a forest where the trees seem to whisper your name. The deeper you go, the louder the whispers become - but no one else is around. What do the trees want from you?


2. The Forgotten Doll


A child finds an old doll buried in the backyard. At night, the doll moves on its own, leaving cryptic messages written in dust. What is it trying to tell the child?


3. The Vanishing Room


In a hotel, a guest discovers a room that doesn’t appear on any floor plan. Every time they enter, the room changes - sometimes it’s a library, other times a prison cell. What is the room hiding?


4. The Last Broadcast


A radio station receives a mysterious signal that predicts disasters before they happen. When the predictions start involving the station itself, the staff must uncover the source before it’s too late.


5. The Shadow in the Photograph


A photographer notices a shadowy figure appearing in every picture they take, even when no one else is around. The figure seems to be getting closer with each photo. Who or what is it?


These prompts are just the tip of the iceberg. If you want even more ideas, check out this collection of scary story writing prompts that can push your creativity to new heights.


Close-up view of a flickering candle casting shadows on a cracked wall
A flickering candle creating eerie shadows perfect for a horror story setting

Tips for Writing Horror That Sticks


Writing scary stories isn’t just about gore or jump scares. It’s about creating an atmosphere that lingers in the reader’s mind. Here are some tips I swear by:


  • Use the power of suggestion. Sometimes what you don’t say is scarier than what you do.

  • Keep your sentences short and punchy. It builds tension and keeps the pace moving.

  • Play with the unknown. Fear of the unknown is universal. Let your readers fill in the blanks.

  • Create relatable characters. Readers care more about what happens if they connect emotionally.

  • Use setting as a character. A creepy house, a foggy street, or a deserted carnival can add layers of fear.

  • Experiment with unreliable narrators. Make your readers question what’s real.


For example, instead of describing a monster in detail, hint at its presence through sounds, shadows, or the reactions of your characters. This technique keeps readers on edge and lets their imagination do the heavy lifting.


Where to Share Your Scary Stories


Once you’ve crafted your chilling tale, why keep it to yourself? Sharing your work can be just as thrilling as writing it. Here are some places to consider:


  • Online writing communities like Wattpad or Reddit’s r/nosleep.

  • Horror-themed forums and blogs where fans gather to discuss and share.

  • Local writing groups or workshops for feedback and support.

  • Social media platforms using hashtags like #HorrorWriting or #ScaryStories.

  • Submitting to anthologies or contests focused on horror and speculative fiction.


Sharing your stories not only builds your confidence but also connects you with others who love the genre. Plus, feedback can help you sharpen your skills and discover new angles.


Keep the Fear Alive


Writing scary stories is a thrilling adventure. It’s about pushing boundaries, exploring fears, and crafting worlds that haunt readers long after the last word. Whether you’re a seasoned writer or just starting out, using prompts can be your secret weapon to keep the ideas flowing.


So, what are you waiting for? Grab a notebook, pick a prompt, and let your imagination run wild. The next great horror story could be just a few words away.


Happy writing - and watch out for what’s lurking in the shadows!

Comments


Created by Jason J. Cross

  • Wix Facebook page
  • Wix Twitter page
  • Google+ Social Icon
  • Instagram Social Icon
  • Amazon Social Icon
  • YouTube Square
  • Smashwords eBooks
!
Widget Didn’t Load
Check your internet and refresh this page.
If that doesn’t work, contact us.
bottom of page